My favorite place to fish for trout is a tie. There is small lake by my camp called Chapmen Lake that has a small stream called west branch. My other favorite is Salmon Creek in Tionesta.
My favorite place is Sugar Creek. It runs through a place called Cooperstown which is N-NW of Franklin. I don't normally start fishing until about 2 weeks after season opens since I can only go on weekends.
My favorite place to go first day is Neshannock Creek in New Castle at a place called "The cinders"... It will be crowded but still fun... What bait does everyone like to use initially. I tend to go with a spinner for first hour or so then switch to spinning minnows...
Personally, I like to use a niti in a silver model in the 1 1/2 or 2 inch size. If you have never heard of it google it. It is a great lure that works for a bunch of species and is responsible for some of the biggest trout that i have ever caught. If those don't work then I tend to go to multiple colors and blade combo's of joe fly's.